ShiftED Podcast
ShiftED Podcast
Global voices. Québec perspectives.
ShiftED brings educators, researchers, authors, and thinkers from Québec and around the world into conversation about what’s shifting in education—from John Hattie to Peter Gray and beyond.
Each conversation asks: What does this mean for education in Québec?
Rooted in LEARN’s mission, ShiftED connects big ideas to the realities of Québec’s English-language education community.
Real conversations. Shifting perspectives.
ShiftED Podcast
ShiftED Podcast #113: Beyond Behaviour — Connection Before Correction, In Conversation with Kerrie Bremner
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
What if the key to better classroom management isn't more rules, but stronger relationships?
In this episode of ShiftED, we welcome Kerrie Bremner, Inclusion and Special Education Consultant supporting Québec's Centre of Excellence for Behaviour Management. Drawing on her classroom experience, Kerrie challenges us to look beyond challenging behaviour and rethink how we connect with students. From her idea of a “relentless welcome” to making inclusion meaningful and manageable, this conversation offers practical insights for educators.
Join us as we explore how small shifts in our responses, relationships and classroom practices can make a meaningful difference for students and teachers alike.
Welcome everybody. Here we are, another uh episode of ShiftED Podcast coming to you as our year uh chugs along here. We're getting a little bit deeper into the school year. Um, Christmas not too far away, but far enough away that we still need to really focus on um what's happening in our classes and making sure that we um kind of leave for the holidays on a positive tone with our students. Um, I am really pleased to have Carrie Bremner here. Really excited to have you here. Um I know that you've been in this field for quite some time, and there's I'm sure lots of situations that kind of brought you here. Do you think you could pull out a couple of those like points that kind of brought you to the center of excellence in your career? I know that you've been in education for quite some time, but um maybe just lay a little bit of a foundation on how you came to this uh position of working with the centers of uh excellence.
SPEAKER_01So I was a teacher for about uh 10 to 11 years, and I was working in a lower-income neighborhood. I taught specifically 15 to 18-year-olds, students with special needs. And whether they had learning difficulties or they had big gaps in their learning and they were extreme smart, I typically had a rough group, and that's from the beginning. So when I first started teaching, you naturally are going to lean on teachers that have been there a really, really long time. And when you do that, sometimes their approach can be more consequence-based. And so when I first started teaching, I would try this consequence-based approach with my students and constantly find myself in nonstop power struggles. And in terms of teacher longevity, that's not sustainable. So I started to really dive into trauma-informed practice and it changed my entire perspective on how to approach different learners, especially learners that are going to push back. And it was a total game changer for me. Um, I developed really strong relationships with some of the hardest-to-reach students. Some of them have reached out to me years later. I never had to raise my voice again. I was able to handle a lot of situations within the classroom, maintain leadership. It was, and I actually was able to do a lot of cool things with students. I was able to take them on trips through YMCA youth exchanges. I was more willing to take risks with them. And during that time, I was also looking at what are my next steps. And the school ended up opening an alternative setting for grades seven, eight, and nine, a pilot project called the Thrive Program, which is essentially a landing spot for some of our harder-to-reach students that were entering high school or were in secondary one, two, and three. And so those students either had absenteeism issues or behavior problems, and we would implement uh individualized plans for them to keep them regulated. And so I got a lot of training to be able to do that. I worked alongside psychologists and behavior consultants, and I found myself always talking about these types of interventions within my school, and I couldn't stop talking about it. So someone approached me and said, you know, maybe you should think about either going into administration or consulting. And I knew someone at Riverside School Board who was the coordinator of complimentary services, and I was kind of flirting with the idea of going into consulting. And one day uh she said she had a six-month contract for me, and I took it.
SPEAKER_00And
SPEAKER_01I have not looked back because now I have the opportunity to continue talking about it and I have a much wider audience, and now I'm collaborating with the CEBM. So that's kind of what uh what led me here. Uh just experience teaching. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. We're so happy to have you uh a part of this because look classrooms are not getting easier. Um they seem to be more challenging, particularly here in Quebec. Um, as we um juggle, you know, inclusivity. Um but maybe before we dive into that, like oftentimes like you mentioned something about relationships there right at the start, right? And as soon as you started developing relationships with your students, that classroom management became a little bit easier. But I often wonder about what how do you approach relationships in in a school environment, right? It's not the same approach you would take with, you know, somebody that, you know, I mean, obviously these are not your peers, but like how do you go about coaching um teachers on uh the keys of what that relationship is and and how they could start developing it with a teacher-to-student kind of relationship?
SPEAKER_01So the first thing that you want to look at is this is something that has irritated me for years, is you go to these uh professional development uh trainings and you'll see on a list of classroom management techniques, for example, it'll be bulleted and they will say, make rules and expectations together, assign seating, build relationships, and then it'll go on with a whole bunch of other things. As if build relationships is something that we inherently are able to do.
SPEAKER_00Right. It's just a bullet point. Like, of course you can do that.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. Of course you have the skill sets to do that. But being able to build relationships with students, especially hard-to-reach students, starts with doing the reflection work on whether or not you have the skill sets to do that, to take inventory of relationships that you actually have and maintained and whether or not they are healthy. Because the skill sets that you need to maintain those relationships are the same skill sets that you're going to need with those students. So you have to bring that type of approach to building relationships, especially with the hard-to-reach students who are going to keep you at arm's length. So there are ways that you can approach it. So let's say you're a beginner and you're saying, wow, building relationships is something that's really difficult for me. Maybe you're an excellent pedagogue, maybe you deliver an excellent lesson, but the relationship piece is something you have to work on. The moment you recognize you need to work on it, that's half the battle. Because an entry point for a student can literally be just a greeting that happens every day. What I call like relentless welcome. That can be the starting point. And once you get comfortable with that, I'd say your next entry point to building relationships is the idea of sameness, which comes from Dr. Gordon Newfeld, which is just trying to find one thing that is somewhat similar between you and that student. And if you can do that with your class, do that greeting every day, find some kind of sameness, it's going to start to organically build that relationship. But it really does start with you reflecting on your ability to do that and being uncomfortable with it and being vulnerable with yourself. That's where it starts.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, it's not easy work for a teacher, right? To I mean, it's like another layer on top of what they have to do. Like you mentioned, like you could deliver a great lesson plan, excellent pedagogue. But it seems like that foundation of relationships is so important that if you don't have that, then all that greatness that you're you're putting out there is just going to be you know hitting a dead wall. Is is is that too much to say, or is that something that that you've seen in your practice?
SPEAKER_01Well, there are some students that have they're just inherently motivated to succeed, right? They have pillars at home, they have strong relationships at home, they have consistent adults in their lives. Those students may not be looking to you for a relationship because they don't need to trust you. They trust themselves, they trust their people at home. They can they'll do the work, they'll buy into what you're selling up there. But a student that doesn't have a consistent adult at home or doesn't trust adults, will have and has maybe difficulty learning, is going to see you as the person that is putting consistent demands on them,
SPEAKER_00right?
SPEAKER_01And causing a stress response.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01And so those are the students that you really, if you want to get through to them and if you want to make your year as easy as possible, you have to shift gears there. You have to put the work into the relationship so they'll bend in your direction a bit academically. That's why we see so many students go into refusal as well.
SPEAKER_00It takes
SPEAKER_01vulnerability to say I need help. It takes vulnerability to say I'm having trouble with this, I can't read, right? And we will bring that to someone that we trust, and we will bring that to someone that we think feels like we matter. And so we have to make that intentional shift.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I love I love your bringing up uh uh Dr. Neufeld, um, huge fan of his attachment theory. And like he came on the cast and we talked about that attachment theory, and he seemed to say that that they have to attach to you somehow, you know, and like and you have to create that openness for them to be able to come in and detach to you. Um if we were to just kind of look at like understanding behavior a little bit, um you know, we often describe, you know, defiant or disruptive behavior from students and stuff. How do we understand what's behind that? Like, because oftentimes kids are coming in with a behavior that there's a reason for it. It's not just like I feel like being this way today. Um can you talk a little bit about that? Of like, how do we understand the behavior or what's happening behind that behavior without not being accusatory or like pushing the kid further away? Like, how do we manage that? Like finding out what is behind this disruption I get all the time, or talking out loud, or not listening, or etc.
SPEAKER_01So the very first thing you have to do is approach that behavior with curiosity, right? We have to approach it with curiosity and start to ask ourselves what is the unmet need here? What is what has happened to this child? What need has not been met? What do they need right now? The thing is, is we cannot take the behavior personally, even if it's happening in front of us every single day. Most of the time, it's not about you. But if you take the behavior personally and you're not doing that curiosity work and that questioning, you're going to burn out. Okay?
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01So we need to approach students with curiosity and ask ourselves, I wonder if they're hungry. I wonder how their morning went. I wonder what that bus ride was like. Are there any potential underlying health issues here? Is there chronic stress in their life? Do they have a traumatic background? Are executive functioning skills a problem here? Is this a sensory issue?
SPEAKER_00Right?
SPEAKER_01There's tons of reasons why a student may be behaving in a certain way, but that could be the manifestation of an unmet need that could a lot of the time easily be remedied if we ask the question. And I will say a lot of the time it's adults talking to adults asking these questions. And seldom do we just pull a student aside when they're calm and ask them straight up, hey, you have a lot of trouble this morning. What's up? What can I put in place to make it easier for you? You know, and the insight that you get when you ask kids directly if you're a trusted adult is a lot of the times the answer to the problem, right? We have a tendency to be fixers in education. Teachers are fixers, administrators are fixers, parents are fixers. We don't want someone to be in distress, we don't want someone to stress out our other students. So we push to fix, but we need to take a step back and approach it with curiosity and seeing where the unmet need is.
SPEAKER_00And
SPEAKER_01the thing is, is when we lose sight of the unmet need, we will be bogged down by behavior. And if you look at some of the statistics for teacher burnout, a lot of the things that are being cited are behavior related. And that is what is really, I believe, hurting our teacher retention rate. Is that the training needs to really be about the psychoeducation of students and really understanding how unmet needs manifest in behaviors that don't allow for access to learning?
SPEAKER_00That's really interesting. Yeah, because you you could be faced, you just don't know, right? Like a child comes into your classroom and I mean, where is this coming from?
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00And there could be so many layers to it. Um what what tips and tricks do you like? I liked your example of just going up to the child and asking, you know, like you seem a little off this morning. Is there anything I can, you know, like what are some other ways that teachers can kind of like not be invasive, but be that support and not try to fix things? Because I think that I I agree with you. I think that we get obsessed with we have all the answers, right? We want to have all the answers. We don't like it when we don't have the answers. But this is kind of human behavior, and there's no real right answers. It depends, it's like it fluctuates. What what kind of advice do you give to teachers? You know, other than just coming at, you know, I mean, is that the simplest way, or are there other ways that you can kind of like ease into this um support without pressure or without, you know, um getting too close to maybe something that they're not ready to talk about or reveal?
SPEAKER_01So you have a student, let's say, is keeping you at arm's length, right? We're not there yet to have a vulnerable conversation, they're most likely not going to answer us. That's okay. What we need to do as a staff is really look at when that behavior happens and look at the different perspectives of the adults. So, what do you think happened five or six minutes before that behavior happened? What were the child child indicators that they were becoming a little bit disorganized? And you'll be surprised. Some people might notice things that you don't. Oh, I noticed he was tapping his foot at his desk. Oh, I noticed it was the moment you said we're gonna switch to math. It was right before phys ed. It was, oh, he got dropped off by this parent today. Oh, okay. When we do that planning together, that means that we're able to put things in place to alleviate some stress for that student. Like when we can make those predictions for them and put things in place, the likelihood of behavior will be reduced. And that means that we're not even the student doesn't even know that that's happening, but we're removing barriers to learning without them even noticing it's happening. Because collaboratively, I call it full port full court press. We're we're coming at this as a team to ensure that that behavior is reduced or doesn't happen so that if they're not available to have that conversation, we don't have to have it. The adults will have it and put the support in place. And eventually, if those behaviors are reduced and that student comes in in the green or is in the green in class, hey, maybe after a couple of months we've opened the door to actually talk to them. So if we have a hard-to-reach student, there are ways where we don't have to necessarily engage with them directly, but putting things in place, being able to make predictions and working together as a team can allow you sometimes access to that student.
SPEAKER_00Wow, I love that. Um great advice. Um and I know I know our teachers practice these, um, but it's always good to like reinforce that because sometimes you just feel like you're not making any progress, right? It's like it's always the same, you know, it's like groundhog day all over again.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and
SPEAKER_00you're having to rebuild all the time. And it can be kind of demoralizing for a teacher, but again, what you said is it's not about you, you know, like these behaviors are the luggage of that child that is coming in with it's not a personal thing. And I think it's really hard sometimes because we are human when we feel um teachers that it's hard not to at times. Um how do you coach teachers on it's not about you? Is that something that you guys look at? Um because I can see it like I felt that before as well when I was working with my work-oriented kids who are, you know, tough kids to to connect with. It takes work. Um, but I always felt, you know, I was doing something that wasn't good enough to to connect with them or to, you know, get them excited about learning. Um, how do you shift that mindset in a teacher that's kind of like, man, I'm just struggling with this so that we can retain them, I guess. You know, it's like one plus one equals two. Like, where do you where do you stand on that? And how do you kind of help a teacher through that kind of like, it's not about me?
SPEAKER_01So the moment a teacher gets in touch with me and says, I am struggling, I'm having a hard time, and they want help, great. That's a teacher that wants to learn, and I can work with this teacher. So immediately I go into we're gonna do the psychoeducation, we're gonna do the wise of behavior together so that you have the lens to actually see what's happening in front of you. So that way they can see, oh, it's not about me. This is what's happening. Oh, this kid, yes, I see this executive skill deficit, I see this, I see that. Okay, then they start to relax because it's starting to make sense what's happening in front of them. Once they have the psychoeducation, now we can put planning in place. The big thing here, and you said something about seeing progress. In coaching, one of my biggest strategies is to shift a teacher's lens so that they see progress when it's happening. The thing is, some teachers will look at the big picture and say, he's still failing. He's still failing, he's failing math, he doesn't talk to me, or something like that. We look at his absenteeism. Well, the absenteeism has dropped significantly. And last year he had a 30 and now he has a 45. Well, something's happening here, right? And so a big part of teacher burnout is self-efficacy, the feeling that they're just not being effective. And I really like to shift all to see have teachers see all the good that is happening and seeing that maybe this year, passing the year is not in the cards for this particular student. Maybe this year, them becoming super close with you is not in the cards for them. Maybe that's gonna take years. But them actually making eye contact you and saying hello when you greet them in the morning when they weren't doing that a few weeks ago is huge progress. So the more, the more I can speak with teachers and have them see the successes that are happening that are eventually going to culminate into a bigger success over the years if there's a lot of teamwork, then then they feel better and they have the energy to continue. So it's a lot of conversations, it's a lot of psychoeducation and a lot of conversations, feedback, how's it going, and iteration, reflection, modeling, things like that.
SPEAKER_00Right. Amazing. So we have inclusion here in in our classrooms here in Quebec. I hear a lot from teachers about the struggles of differentiating between all of these. So, like imagine one student now throw, you know, multiply that times, you know, five or six or however many. Where where do you start with that conversation with a teacher? Because I hear it very often, and I know there's resources out there and there's support out there, but it still seems to be very overwhelming, and that you're asking me to do five lesson plans. Like, and I and I often get that as kind of a misconception in differentiation that it's not really about creating five different lesson plans. It's about what, Carrie?
SPEAKER_01Like
SPEAKER_00what what what are we trying to do with this inclusion of of making everybody feel they belong, which I think is so important for the future of these kids as they leave school, of just how they are in society.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But like it's a challenge for teachers. How how do you go about explaining inclusion or like what really needs to be the focus of it rather than five lesson plans that I have to create for all these different learners I have in my class?
SPEAKER_01Okay. So one thing I have seen as a shift is that I see that teachers are not seeing inclusion as merely integration. Teachers are seeing that inclusion is not just having a kid breathe the air within the four walls of your classroom. I have to say that I see that, that teachers really are trying to shift towards inclusion. And inclusion sounds simple, but it's not easy. So I'm going to paint a picture of what inclusion is, but I just be mindful that I recognize that none of this is easy. But inclusion really does encapsulate allowing a student to feel that they belong, to feel that they have access to learning, that they have opportunities for participation, that they can. Contribute because that is a human need, right? Being able to contribute allows you to feel like you matter,
SPEAKER_00and
SPEAKER_01providing individual support. That's the definition of inclusion. Okay. Now, in terms of lesson planning and this idea of I have to do five lessons to allow access and belonging and contribution and all that, that's a misconception. There, I like to think about now. I'm talking specifically about executing a lesson. Okay. When we think about inclusion, I like to think about lesson planning as a highway. So I want everyone in that room to get onto the highway. Everyone in that room is going to hear this lesson together. Okay. That lesson is going to have multiple highway entry points. So you're going to hear me speak. The writing will be on the smart board or on the board. There'll maybe be an um a visual component, and they'll have access to it after to read on their own if they want. So no matter how you access learning, you have multiple entry points onto the highway. So when you're doing your lesson, you just have to think, how can I add as many entry points to the highway when doing this lesson? And that really just means retrofitting what you have. Or when planning a new lesson, just thinking, how can I make as many entry points as possible without burning myself out? And sometimes it's just a visual text and speaking and maybe a check-in or something written. Now, we're all on the highway together, but we have to get off. The problem is that we're all driving different vehicles and we're going to need different types of off-ramps in order to successfully get off the highway, right? So that means looking at and being flexible about different forms of production. How is the student going to show me what they've learned? So ensuring that we're following the curriculum and really pinpointing what exactly am I assessing here? And how many exit points can I put on my highway so that I'm truly just assessing this particular thing. So inclusion is about building your highway at multiple entry points and building it with as many exit points as possible, being mindful of the different vehicles. Like I said though, simple, not easy.
SPEAKER_00Right. I love the analogy. It's such it's so clear. Um, it's a great one. I love that one. Um yes, uh complicated, complex, right?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00I often get this like I love listening to what you're saying, and like, how do we get from you know, some a presentation or a webinar or a workshop? How do I get that idea and bring it into my class? Because we see we give tons of professional development, right? There's support out there. You can find so many webinars, maybe not just only here in Quebec, but across Canada, there's often free webinars on all kinds of different um topics where you can go and get information. One of the things that I see often is that it never really makes it back to the classroom. Um, and John Hattie's done a ton of research on it's probably one of the lowest return rates on investment is attending a workshop because it never seems to make it back.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00How do you ensure that like just that analogy? And then, you know, how do they take that and then apply it into the classroom so that something concrete could happen out of it?
SPEAKER_01Okay, so what I mentioned, there's a lot of moving pieces there, right? We have to understand the students' needs, right? We have to understand how to do flexible, flexible pedagogy and differentiation, right? We have to understand and be comfortable with the different exit points. That's not just going to happen overnight. So if you have a teacher that goes to an inclusion workshop and they talk for four hours about the highway, that's a lot of things that you have to implement. The problem is, is when we have PD, there's that bait, what you're referring to is the implementation gap, right? Why are teachers not able to implement it? It's because there's too much. Teachers are taxed too much cognitively. They're dealing with behavior, IEPs, meetings, reports, all this stuff. What we have to be doing is we have to be focused on one particular thing that that teacher can implement that year. But that thing has to be something that is relevant to them, something that makes sense for their classroom, something they have the capacity to sink their teeth into, not ability. I believe they all have the ability, but a capacity. Does that teacher have the energy to do that right now? Is this the right time? Um, all of those things have to align in order for something to be implemented. But that's not even enough. So let's say we just focus on one part of inclusion, a teacher buys in, they want to focus on one thing, they want to learn about differentiated instruction. The thing is about teacher burnout is that even if that teacher is 100% in, the moment stress starts to take over, they are naturally going to lean on old habits to get as comfortable as possible. It's a protective measure, right? So we got to make sure that that teacher is in the right mindset and comfortable enough and relaxed enough to be able to be consistent. Another thing is that they need to have a sounding board for feedback and a trusting person that they can sh do the lesson in front of, fall on their face, and realize that failure is feedback and have someone say, This part was great, this part was great, this part we need to rework, let's try it again, have them go and then have that person focus on that progress I was talking about, that small progress. We want to build self-efficacy, we want to build confidence, we want them to see progress in that one little thing. If we have a teacher work on one part of that inclusion highway and master it because they have a coach, a sounding board, they get good feedback, they are learning new things, they're feeling successful, the chances are really, really good that they'll be ready the next year to implement a second thing. And look at that, within four or five years, now we have an inclusion master. But that's the timeline,
SPEAKER_00that's
SPEAKER_01the reality, right? Um, but it really does take, if you look at the literature on the implementation gap, it takes coaching, right? So even in my role, I've thought when I first started, I said, I love public speaking. I'm just gonna train people nonstop, you know. And then I said to Catherine Korra one day, I said, What am I gonna do when I finish talking to everyone at Riverside School Board? You know, and she says, Carrie, we've been talking about the same things for 20 years, you know, across the province, across the nation,
SPEAKER_00right?
SPEAKER_01Like there, these things they don't stick. And then I started to ask myself, I have teachers that buy in so much to what I'm saying. They want to learn, but this it doesn't stick. And when I started to read about it, I was like, well, of course it doesn't stick. There's too much going on, and they don't have a pillar to follow them. And so last year I sort of shifted my role as much as I could with the time that I had to put myself in a coaching position to try and close that implementation gap. But truly that's what it takes.
SPEAKER_00Yeah,
SPEAKER_01it takes that.
SPEAKER_00It's that long-term vision too, right? Like you're not gonna do it all this year, no, you know, but I love that. Choose one thing that you know will help, or at least create progress towards what you're building towards and have that long-term plan um of how you're going to, you know, adjust. Um, and these aren't major overhauls, these are like they're manageable, right? You're doing small tweaks to how you would deliver something or what resource you might provide for this student, or
SPEAKER_01yeah,
SPEAKER_00like you're not having to redesign who you are as a teacher.
SPEAKER_01No, it's even learning about tools like Katherine Coras said something about the room being uh a partner in co-regulation, you know, looking at the space, your actual real estate of your classroom, and redesigning it so that you can partner up with the space to help you with co-regulation, so that you can have a kid kind of calm down over here, or have kids do remediation work with you and use another space for students that need maybe enrichment or but really looking at the space also as a partner to help you reach your goal. It's a real lens shift.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, totally, totally. Well, I want to thank you. I mean, I could just keep talking with you for hours and hours. I want to respect our time. Um, Carrie, it's so insightful. Um, I think what you guys do too over at the Center of Excellence is like outstanding. And and I I encourage listeners to go and check out the resources. They have webinars, they have posters, they have all kinds of amazing resources that if you're feeling like you're hitting a wall, find help. And the Center of Excellence is oftentimes the best starting spot for you to go. Um and I want to leave with one that one quote that you said that failure is feedback. We don't think about like that is a a seed I'm gonna take with me from this conversation. Um I I always say, you know, failure is learning, but it's feedback, you know, so that you can do something about it rather than just I got a seventy six. well, Carrie, thanks so much. I hope um you can come back and join me. I I know that we could talk for another half an hour easily, um, but I I do really appreciate your your insights into um into uh behavior management in classrooms and helping teachers uh cope with uh all of those issues that come up with it.
SPEAKER_01Well, thank you so much for having me. It was a lot of fun.